A Year of Violence Against India's Catholics
Nirmala Carvalho
As Catholic believers across India gather to celebrate
the birth of Jesus, many will carry physical or
emotional scars as a result of attacks launched
by Hindu extremists over the past year.
Many incidents of violence against both Catholics
and Protestants went unreported, since the police
often refused to record the victims' complaints,
but by last June the number of violent attacks
recorded by Christian organizations had reached
over 200. This number was expected to double by
year's end. Catholics, who make up about 29 percent
of Christians in India according to Operation
World, were often targeted in these attacks.
"This year Hindu extremists have beaten
our priests, assaulted our nuns, broken crosses
and urinated on sacred vessels," said Dr.
John Dayal, president of the All India Catholic
Union. "These acts of desecration show the
true nature of the attackers."
Attacks were reported in Haryana, Rajasthan,
Gujarat, Punjab, Uttar Pradesh and the states
of tribal central India.
"We also have reports of attacks on Catholic
clergy from West Bengal in the east to Andhra
Pradesh in south central India," Dayal said.
Desecration of religious objects is common in
such attacks. Police, however, often ignore the
religious aspects of a complaint because of the
legal implications.
"Indian law has specific provisions against
actions that sow seeds of hatred between communities,"
Dayal explained. "We also have laws against
violence directed at a specific religious or other
minority group. Still other laws come into operation
if the victims are Dalits."
In several cases of religiously-motivated violence
this year, police have refused to record a "First
Information Report," leaving the victims
with no legal means to pursue their complaints.
In other cases, desecration of religious objects
is recorded only as petty crime or theft.
Rajasthan has the highest number of recorded
incidents. In February, Rajasthan's state government
nnounced plans to adopt anti- conversion legislation,
echoing laws already in force in Orissa, Madhya
Pradesh, Chattisgarh and Arunachal Pradesh.
Gujarat state passed a similar law in March 2003,
but the law has not yet been enforced.
The Rev. Dr. Babu Joseph, director of communications
and spokesperson for the Catholic Bishops' Conference
of India, told Compass the total number of violent
incidents reported had declined over the past
year.
"This is partly due to the change of government
in 2004, and its policies of inclusiveness ...
which have given a better sense of security to
those who suffered harassment," Joseph claimed.
Other Christian leaders rejected Joseph's claim
of decreasing religious violence, but all agree
that anti-Christian violence surged after the
pro-Hindu Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) won federal
elections held in 1998. The BJP government was
ousted by a Congress Party-led coalition in new
elections held in April 2004.
Joseph admitted that the situation is still far
from ideal.
"As the spokesperson of the Catholic Bishops'
Conference of India, I ardently hope that the
new year will see a positive change in the social
scenario of India, [so that] people of all religions,
cultures and castes can find an honorable place
to live and develop as equal citizens of our beloved
India."
For his part, Dayal has issued a call for all
church groups to work together in combating violence.
"We must not accuse each other of attracting
violence from extre mist groups," he told
Compass. "Instead we must teach our groups,
both Catholics and Protestant, to be more culturally
sensitive and to exercise common sense."
But once an attack has taken place, he said,
it must be recognized as a crime that should be
denounced and punished.The most recent attack
occurred on December 12, when Hindu extremists
forced more than 40 Dalit Catholic families in
Raipur district of Chattisgarh state to convert
to Hinduism.
The villagers were threatened with loss of employment
and Dalit social benefits if they refused.
Other examples of persecution of Catholic churches
or individuals in 2005 include (alphabetically,
by state):
In Assam state on September 2, armed assailants
murdered Mgr. Nellickal, vicar-general of Tejpur
diocese, on church premises.
In Delhi on May 23, vandals set fire to St. Mary's
church complex in Sabhapur, 150 kilometers (about
93 miles) outside Delhi. They set fire to records
in the director's office and destroyed 200 textbooks
and 1,000 new diaries intended for students. "There
was nothing left in the rooms except the tables,"
said one tribal sister who taught at the school.
In Jharkhand state on September 13, a tribal Catholic
priest identified only as Father Agnos was murdered
during a peaceful demonstration for tribal rights.
A mob of some 40 Hindu extremists armed with knives,
arrows and swords stormed the rally and attempted
to disperse the 3,500 demonstrators. Fr. Agnos
was stabbed in the back and bled to death.
In Kerala state on October 17, four unidentified
men armed with wooden sticks attacked the home
of Bishop Vincent Samuel in Neyyatinkara. Attackers
had destroyed the windows and were about to break
in when a police patrol arrived. A security guard
was injured in the attack, and three vehicles
were damaged.
In Maharashtra on January 23, armed extremists
attacked the Teresian Carmelites Convent, which
runs a home for the elderly in a suburb of Mumbai.
The door and cross were smashed. Pamphlets left
by the attackers encouraged the nuns to "Run
away - or we will come back. This country is ours.
Now it is the cross; the next time it will be
your heads."
* In Manipur on April 19, a mob of 200 extremists
armed with sickles and torches set fire to a Catholic
church in Lamding village.
* In Rajasthan on June 9, mobs of extremists
attacked two Catholic convents; on June 11, a
mob attacked a third convent and held the nuns
captive overnight; on June 12, extremists broke
into the Holy Trinity Church in Jaipur, capital
of Rajasthan, and threw rotten eggs and blue-colored
water at a shrine dedicated to the infant
Jesus.
* October 16 [in Rajasthan state], members of
the Hindu extremist group Rashtriya Swayamsevak
Sangh (RSS) accused Catholics holding a procession
of planning forced conversions among tribal people
in Udaipur district. Bishop Joseph Pathalil's
car was pelted with stones as he left the procession,
but he escaped unharmed.
* Also in Udaipur district, on October 25 five
nuns waiting at a bus stop were beaten with sticks.
* In West Bengal on February 12, police arrested
81-year-old Father. Luciano Colussi, vicar-general
of Krishnagar, giving no reason or explanation
for his arrest.
Copyright 2005 Compass Direct
Compass Direct Feature News is distributed as
available to raise awareness of Christians worldwide
who are persecuted for their faith. Articles may
be reprinted by active subscribers only. For subscription
information, contact: 949-862-0304 or info@...
Many incidents of violence against both Catholics
and Protestants went unreported, since the police
often refused to record the victims' complaints,
but by last June the number of violent attacks
recorded by Christian organizations had reached
over 200. This number was expected to double by
year's end. Catholics, who make up about 29 percent
of Christians in India according to Operation
World, were often targeted in these attacks.
"This year Hindu extremists have beaten
our priests, assaulted our nuns, broken crosses
and urinated on sacred vessels," said Dr.
John Dayal, president of the All India Catholic
Union. "These acts of desecration show the
true nature of the attackers."
Attacks were reported in Haryana, Rajasthan,
Gujarat, Punjab, Uttar Pradesh and the states
of tribal central India.
"We also have reports of attacks on Catholic
clergy from West Bengal in the east to Andhra
Pradesh in south central India," Dayal said.
Desecration of religious objects is common in
such attacks. Police, however, often ignore the
religious aspects of a complaint because of the
legal implications.
"Indian law has specific provisions against
actions that sow seeds of hatred between communities,"
Dayal explained. "We also have laws against
violence directed at a specific religious or other
minority group. Still other laws come into operation
if the victims are Dalits."
In several cases of religiously-motivated violence
this year, police have refused to record a "First
Information Report," leaving the victims
with no legal means to pursue their complaints.
In other cases, desecration of religious objects
is recorded only as petty crime or theft.
Rajasthan has the highest number of recorded
incidents. In February, Rajasthan's state government
announced plans to adopt anti- conversion legislation,
echoing laws already in force in Orissa, Madhya
Pradesh, Chattisgarh and Arunachal Pradesh.
Gujarat state passed a similar law in March 2003,
but the law has not yet been enforced.
The Rev. Dr. Babu Joseph, director of communications
and spokesperson for the Catholic Bishops' Conference
of India, told Compass the total number of violent
incidents reported had declined over the past
year.
"This is partly due to the change of government
in 2004, and its policies of inclusiveness ...
which have given a better sense of security to
those who suffered harassment," Joseph claimed.
Other Christian leaders rejected Joseph's claim
of decreasing religious violence, but all agree
that anti-Christian violence surged after the
pro-Hindu Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) won federal
elections held in 1998. The BJP government was
ousted by a Congress Party-led coalition in new
elections held in April 2004.
Joseph admitted that the situation is still far
from ideal.
"As the spokesperson of the Catholic Bishops'
Conference of India, I ardently hope that the
new year will see a positive change in the social
scenario of India, [so that] people of all religions,
cultures and castes can find an honorable place
to live and develop as equal citizens of our beloved
India."
For his part, Dayal has issued a call for all
church groups to work together in combating violence.
"We must not accuse each other of attracting
violence from extremist groups," he told
Compass. "Instead we must teach our groups,
both Catholics and Protestant, to be more culturally
sensitive and to exercise common sense."
But once an attack has taken place, he said,
it must be recognized as a crime that should be
denounced and punished.
The most recent attack occurred on December 12,
when Hindu extremists forced more than 40 Dalit
Catholic families in Raipur district of Chattisgarh
state to convert to Hinduism.
The villagers were threatened with loss of employment
and Dalit social benefits if they refused.
Other examples of persecution of Catholic churches
or individuals in 2005 include (alphabetically,
by state):
* In Assam state on September 2, armed assailants
murdered Mgr. Nellickal, vicar-general of Tejpur
diocese, on church premises.
* In Delhi on May 23, vandals set fire to St.
Mary's church complex in Sabhapur, 150 kilometers
(about 93 miles) outside Delhi. They set fire
to records in the director's office and destroyed
200 textbooks and 1,000 new diaries intended for
students. "There was nothing left in the
rooms except the tables," said one tribal
sister who taught at the school.
* In Jharkhand state on September 13, a tribal
Catholic priest identified only as Father Agnos
was murdered during a peaceful demonstration for
tribal rights. A mob of some 40 Hindu extremists
armed with knives, arrows and swords stormed the
rally and attempted to disperse the 3,500 demonstrators.
Fr. Agnos was stabbed in the back and bled to
death.
* In Kerala state on October 17, four unidentified
men armed with wooden sticks attacked the home
of Bishop Vincent Samuel in Neyyatinkara. Attackers
had destroyed the windows and were about to break
in when a police patrol arrived. A security guard
was injured in the attack, and three vehicles
were damaged.
* In Maharashtra on January 23, armed extremists
attacked the Teresian Carmelites Convent, which
runs a home for the elderly in a suburb of Mumbai.
The door and cross were smashed. Pamphlets left
by the attackers encouraged the nuns to "Run
away - or we will come back. This country is ours.
Now it is the cross; the next time it will be
your heads."
* In Manipur on April 19, a mob of 200 extremists
armed with sickles and torches set fire to a Catholic
church in Lamding village.
* In Rajasthan on June 9, mobs of extremists
attacked two Catholic convents; on June 11, a
mob attacked a third convent and held the nuns
captive overnight; on June 12, extremists broke
into the Holy Trinity Church in Jaipur, capital
of Rajasthan, and threw rotten eggs and blue-colored
water at a shrine dedicated to the infant
Jesus.
* October 16 [in Rajasthan state], members of
the Hindu extremist group Rashtriya Swayamsevak
Sangh (RSS) accused Catholics holding a procession
of planning forced conversions among tribal people
in Udaipur district. Bishop Joseph Pathalil's
car was pelted with stones as he left the procession,
but he escaped unharmed.
* Also in Udaipur district, on October 25 five
nuns waiting at a bus stop were beaten with sticks.
* In West Bengal on February 12, police arrested
81-year-old Father. Luciano Colussi, vicar-general
of Krishnagar, giving no reason or explanation
for his arrest.
|